The euphotic zone

Photosynthesis runs on photosynthetically available radiation, PAR: the photons between 400 and 700 nm. The depth where PAR falls to 1 percent of its value just below the surface is the conventional bottom of the euphotic zone. This guide finds that depth for the Jerlov types, and compares it with the depths Jerlov measured.

The calculation

jerlov.par_profile() attenuates a surface spectrum down to each depth, counts the photons in the band, and finds where a given fraction is left. The surface spectrum here has the shape of CIE illuminant D65, an assumption that a measured spectrum should replace. Only its shape matters for the fraction, but the package needs to know whether it is energy or photons, since PAR counts photons:

>>> import numpy as np
>>> import jerlov
>>> wl = np.arange(400.0, 701.0, 1.0)
>>> d65_wl, d65 = jerlov.d65()
>>> surface = np.interp(wl, d65_wl, d65)
>>> depths = np.arange(0.0, 201.0, 1.0)
>>> for water_type in ("I", "IB", "II", "III", "1C", "3C", "5C"):
...     kd = jerlov.water(water_type, source="jerlov1976")
...     profile = jerlov.par_profile(surface, wl, depths, kd=kd,
...                                  unit="energy")
...     ten = profile.depth_of_fraction(0.10)
...     one = profile.depth_of_fraction(0.01)
...     print(f"{water_type:>3}   10 percent at {ten:5.1f} m"
...           f"   1 percent at {one:5.1f} m")
  I   10 percent at  60.9 m   1 percent at 166.5 m
 IB   10 percent at  37.5 m   1 percent at  94.1 m
 II   10 percent at  23.0 m   1 percent at  54.2 m
III   10 percent at  14.1 m   1 percent at  32.3 m
 1C   10 percent at  11.2 m   1 percent at  27.0 m
 3C   10 percent at   7.7 m   1 percent at  17.7 m
 5C   10 percent at   5.4 m   1 percent at  11.7 m

Each type’s Kd is applied unchanged all the way down here. That is what the type describes only in the top 10 m.

Against what Jerlov measured

Jerlov (1977) measured the quanta from 350 to 700 nm, the band of his meters, and tabulated the depths of 30, 10, 3 and 1 percent for each type in his Table 2 (jerlov.jerlov1977_quanta()). For a fair comparison the band is his. The calculation is made two ways: with one type all the way down, as above, and letting the type change with depth as it does in the sea (jerlov.descend(), from the profiles of Williamson & Hollins; see The colour of the light at depth):

>>> wl = np.arange(350.0, 701.0, 1.0)
>>> surface = np.interp(wl, d65_wl, d65)
>>> for water_type in ("I", "IA", "IB", "II", "III", "1C", "3C"):
...     bottom = min(200.0, jerlov.profile_depth(water_type))
...     down = depths[depths <= bottom]
...     one_type = jerlov.par_profile(
...         surface, wl, down, kd=jerlov.water(water_type, source="jerlov1976"),
...         unit="energy", band=jerlov.QUANTA_BAND_NM)
...     changing = jerlov.par_profile(
...         surface, wl, down, kd=jerlov.descend(water_type, bottom, wl),
...         unit="energy", band=jerlov.QUANTA_BAND_NM)
...     levels = jerlov.jerlov1977_quanta(water_type)
...     measured = levels.level_depth_m[levels.level_percent.index(1.0)]
...     print(f"{water_type:>3}"
...           f"   one type {one_type.depth_of_fraction(0.01):5.1f} m"
...           f"   descend {changing.depth_of_fraction(0.01):5.1f} m"
...           f"   Jerlov {measured:5.1f} m")
  I   one type 164.4 m   descend 106.2 m   Jerlov 103.0 m
 IA   one type 122.9 m   descend 100.2 m   Jerlov  87.0 m
 IB   one type  93.0 m   descend  93.0 m   Jerlov  70.0 m
 II   one type  53.5 m   descend  53.5 m   Jerlov  52.0 m
III   one type  31.9 m   descend  31.9 m   Jerlov  31.0 m
 1C   one type  26.5 m   descend  27.4 m   Jerlov  27.0 m
 3C   one type  17.4 m   descend  17.4 m   Jerlov  19.0 m

jerlov.jerlov1977_quanta() raises a jerlov.ProvenanceWarning for IA, II and 1C. It is about Jerlov’s Table 5, which for one layer of each prints a Kd that does not follow from his Table 3; the depths compared here are from Table 2 (DATA.md section 22).

From II to 3C the computed depths agree closely with the measured ones. For Jerlov I, one type all the way down puts the 1 percent level far too deep; through the depth profile, in which I typically turns IA and then IB, it comes close to what Jerlov measured.

IA and IB still come out too deep. Why IB does is recorded in DATA.md section 22 and DECISIONS.md sections 53 to 58. The measurements of the SCOR Discoverer Expedition of 1970, two of the 1977 paper’s sources, show the light falling faster below the 10 percent level than above it, so the difference is in the water measured, and a Kd that does not change with depth, from any of the published tables, does not reproduce it.

Where to go next